The Fogcast Episode 34 : Wicked Treasure& Witch Windows w/ Jenni Plumstead

This week on the Fogcast I sit down with Jenni of Newport — owner of Wicked Treasure, self‑published author, creative, and advocate. Our conversation wanders through everything from uranium glass and Magic: The Gathering to eerie childhood memories and unexplained happenings at a local cemetery.

Jenni Plumstead is a Maine‑based creative force whose work lives at Dreamcatcher Antiques in Ellsworth. As the owner of Wicked Treasure, she curates an ever‑evolving collection of oddities, handcrafted pieces, and vintage finds that celebrate the 90s. Her shop has become a haven for people who love the weird, the whimsical, and the wonderfully nostalgic.

Jenni has published a book of poetry and is in the process of working on a novel. Her writing on Substack is focused more on political and social commentary. Jenni is an advocate for community, creativity, and self‑expression. She’s known for uplifting other makers, encouraging people to embrace their quirks, and fostering spaces where individuality is not just accepted but celebrated.

Her interests are as wide‑ranging as her talents. From the glowing allure of uranium glass to the world of card games like Magic the Gathering and Pokemon, Jenni approaches every passion with genuine enthusiasm and a collector’s eye. She’s also no stranger to the eerie side of life — having grown up around the local legends, haunted corners, and the unexplained happenings that give our small towns their character.

Whether she’s crafting, writing, or exploring the strange stories tucked into Maine’s backroads, Jenni brings a sense of wonder to everything she touches. Her work invites others to do the same: to look closer, dig deeper, and find the magic hidden in the everyday.

© 2025. All rights reserved.